Gym Flooring & Mats

BalanceFrom Puzzle Exercise Mat vs IncStores Rubber Gym Flooring Tiles

Quick verdict

Winner on Gym Score: BalanceFrom Puzzle Exercise Mat (77)

IncStores Rubber Gym Flooring Tiles still wins for some buyers — see the fit cards below.

BalanceFrom Puzzle Exercise Mat
Best for
  • · Yoga, stretching, mobility, and floor-based bodyweight work
  • · Pelaton-style cardio setups with a stationary bike or treadmill on top
  • · Kids' play spaces that share weekend duty as an exercise room
IncStores Rubber Gym Flooring Tiles
Best for
  • · Strength athletes who want stall-mat density without the seam-gap problem
  • · Renters and lease-holders who need to remove the floor in one piece later
  • · Garage gyms where one section may need replacement after a drop accident
$120 (6-pack)Buy on Amazon

Spec-by-spec

SpecBalanceFrom Puzzle Exercise MatIncStores Rubber Gym Flooring Tiles
Thickness1/2" or 3/4"8-12mm
Tile Size24" x 24"24" x 24"
MaterialEVA foamVulcanized rubber

BalanceFrom Puzzle Exercise Mat

Strengths
  • +Cheapest mat option
  • +Easy install
  • +Great for cardio/yoga
Weaknesses
  • EVA crushes under barbells
  • Not for strength training

IncStores Rubber Gym Flooring Tiles

Strengths
  • +True vulcanized rubber
  • +8-12mm thickness
  • +Modular install
Weaknesses
  • Pricier than EVA tiles
  • Heavy per tile
Full review: BalanceFrom Puzzle Exercise MatFull review: IncStores Rubber Gym Flooring TilesAll Gym Flooring & Mats