How GymScored is paid: Amazon Associates commission plus brand-direct affiliate (Rogue / REP / Titan when approved). No sponsored placements, no paid reviews, no pay-to-rank. Picks are ranked by the Gym Score formula and nothing else. Read the full disclosure.
Polar H10 Chest Strap vs Garmin HRM 600
Quick verdict
Winner on Gym Score: Garmin HRM 600 (89)
The Garmin HRM 600 wins on Gym Score, and it is the pick if you train on a Garmin watch or bike computer. The Polar H10 is the better buy for everyone else. The H10 is ECG-based, broadcasts ANT+ and Bluetooth together and is the accuracy reference in published validation studies, with a replaceable coin cell rated at about 400 hours. The HRM 600 is Garmin's May 2025 premium strap: rechargeable, able to record a session without a watch, and it sends running dynamics and HRV data to Garmin devices.
Choose the Polar H10 if you want one strap that pairs with your phone, Apple Watch, Zwift, a bike computer and any watch, or you want the reference-grade signal and a battery you can swap in minutes.
Choose the Garmin HRM 600 if you wear a Garmin watch or use an Edge computer and want running dynamics and HRV from your chest, or you like a rechargeable strap that can save a session on its own.

- · Athletes training by heart rate zones using ACSM or Karvonen-derived prescriptions
- · Triathletes and runners who need a strap that pairs with both ANT+ bike computers and BLE phones simultaneously
- · Swimmers wanting onboard memory to record laps where phones and watches do not work underwater

- · Garmin watch or Edge owners who want running dynamics and HRV from the chest
- · Swimmers and team-sport players who train without a watch on
Spec-by-spec
| Spec | Polar H10 Chest Strap | Garmin HRM 600 |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Chest strap | Chest strap |
| Connectivity | ANT+, BLE | ANT+, Bluetooth |
| Battery Life | 400 hours | — |
| Water Resistance | 30 m | — |
| Size | M-XXL (Polar also sells XS-S) | M-XL (Garmin also sells XS-S) |
| Battery | — | Rechargeable, up to 2 months at 1 hour a day (Garmin-stated) |
| Released | — | May 2025 |
Polar H10 Chest Strap
$104.45checked Nov 18, 2026Garmin HRM 600
$156.99checked Nov 18, 2026Polar H10 Chest Strap
- +Reference-grade accuracy
- +ANT+ and BLE dual-band
- +400-hour battery
- +Onboard memory for one session
- +Pairs with everything
- −Chest strap (not for everyone)
- −Pricier than competitors
- −App is optional (subscription pushed)
Garmin HRM 600
- +Rechargeable battery (Garmin-stated up to 2 months at 1 hour a day)
- +Records activities without a paired watch
- +Running dynamics and HRV data for Garmin devices
- +ANT+ and Bluetooth
- −Most of the extra metrics only matter inside the Garmin ecosystem
- −Costs about twice the HRM 200
- −Built-in battery instead of a swappable coin cell
Before you buy: where each one falls short
Polar H10 Chest Strap
- ·You dislike chest straps and the sensation of an elastic band around the ribs during exercise
- ·You only walk or do casual yoga where a wrist monitor is plenty
- ·You are looking for continuous 24/7 HR tracking, which is what wrist optical sensors do better
- ·Your only goal is a daily step count and a rough calorie estimate
- ·Strap chafes during long efforts unless the elastic is moistened or replaced every 12 to 18 months
- ·Battery is a replaceable CR2025 coin cell, which is fine for most but requires a small flat-head to open the pod
- ·Polar pushes Polar Flow Premium and Polar Beat upgrades aggressively, even though the strap itself works fine without any subscription
Garmin HRM 600
- ·You only need an accurate heart-rate signal (the HRM 200 or Polar H10 does that for less)
- ·You are not on Garmin devices
The real tradeoff
The split is extras versus openness. Most of what the HRM 600 adds only pays off inside Garmin's ecosystem, and its battery is built in rather than a swappable coin cell. The H10 asks you to carry a spare coin cell and replace the elastic every 12 to 18 months, and Polar pushes Flow Premium although the strap works without it. Both save a session without a watch, and the H10 holds one session before you must sync.
Skip both if you only need an accurate heart-rate signal on a Garmin watch. The cheaper Garmin HRM 200 does that, and our heart-rate monitor guide covers it. Browse Heart Rate Monitors & Trackers.
Buyer questions
Is the HRM 600 more accurate than the Polar H10?
Not on the evidence we have. The H10 is the strap that published validation studies use as the reference signal. The HRM 600's case is extra data and convenience (running dynamics, HRV, a rechargeable battery, watch-free recording), not a more accurate heart-rate reading.
Does the Garmin HRM 600 work outside the Garmin ecosystem?
It broadcasts heart rate over ANT+ and Bluetooth, so devices and apps that read either can use it. The running dynamics and HRV data are aimed at Garmin watches and bike computers, which is where most of the extra cost pays off.
Which is better for swimming?
The H10 is rated to 30 meters and stores one session in onboard memory, since Bluetooth does not transmit through water. The HRM 600 records without a paired watch too, but our record lists no water rating for it, so check Garmin's spec page before swimming with it.
Which battery is easier to live with?
The H10 uses a replaceable CR2025 coin cell good for about 400 hours, so a spare in your gym bag ends dead-battery sessions. The HRM 600 recharges, and Garmin states up to two months at an hour a day, but you cannot swap in a fresh cell mid-trip.
Your next step