NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs Peloton Tread: Which Treadmill Wins?
The 1750 wins on hardware, the Tread wins on content polish. We compare them on motor, deck, software, and price.
NordicTrack 1750 wins on hardware-per-dollar and is the smart-money pick. Peloton Tread wins if Peloton's content library is what gets you on the machine — and only then.
| Product | Rating | Pros | Cons | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
NordicTrack Commercial 1750 3.5 CHP motor, 60" deck, 12" HD screen with iFIT. | 4.6 |
|
| ~$1,799 | Buy on Amazon |
Peloton Tread 3.0 CHP motor, 59" deck, 23.8" HD screen with Peloton studio content. | 4.5 |
|
| ~$2,995 | Buy Direct |
Prices are approximate and may vary. Please check the latest price before purchasing.
Hardware wins on paper
The 1750 has more motor (3.5 CHP vs 3.0), a slightly longer deck (60" vs 59"), and costs $1,200 less. From a hardware-per-dollar perspective, this is one of the most lopsided comparisons in cardio.
Content wins on emotion
Peloton's content library is the best in the industry. Polished production, charismatic instructors, music licensing that NordicTrack can't match. If you'll genuinely use the content five times a week, the $1,200 hardware premium amortizes fast.
The honest test
Most people buy a Peloton expecting it to be the catalyst that makes them work out. Then they discover the content alone isn't the catalyst — habit is. If you have an existing running habit, NordicTrack's hardware advantage matters. If you're trying to build the habit from scratch, the Peloton's content is genuinely better at hooking you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use the Peloton app on a NordicTrack?+
Yes — the Peloton app works on any device. You'd just lose the auto-incline integration that's specific to the Peloton Tread.
Is the iFIT subscription required?+
Not strictly — the 1750 works as a standard treadmill without it. But the trainer-led incline/speed control is what most people pay for.
Related reviews
Best Treadmill for Home Runners in 2026
We scored 14 treadmills on running performance, build, and software. The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 wins on balance; Sole F80 wins for the no-subscription crowd.
Best Walking Pads to Use Under a Standing Desk
WalkingPad C2 is the apartment hero, Urevo Strol 1 is the value pick, Egofit M1 is the slimmest. We scored 7 walking pads on noise, motor, and under-desk fit.
Affiliate disclosure: GymScored is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. We earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure →