Skip to main content

How GymScored is paid: Amazon Associates commission plus brand-direct affiliate (Rogue / REP / Titan when approved). No sponsored placements, no paid reviews, no pay-to-rank. Picks are ranked by the Gym Score formula and nothing else. Read the full disclosure.

Exercise Bikes

Schwinn IC4 vs Peloton Cross Training Bike

Quick verdict

Winner on Gym Score: Schwinn IC4 (82)

The Schwinn IC4 wins on Gym Score and is the better bike for most buyers. The Peloton people search for is our Peloton Cross Training Bike, the October 2025 model with a 21.5-inch swivel touchscreen and a manual resistance knob, built around the All-Access membership. Both use manual resistance, so the real choice is the ecosystem. The IC4 has no screen but broadcasts Bluetooth FTMS, so it works with Zwift and can ride along with Peloton app classes on your own tablet.

Choose Schwinn IC4 if…

Choose the Schwinn IC4 if you own a tablet, want to pick your own apps (Peloton app, Zwift, Apple Fitness+), or want dual-sided SPD and toe-cage pedals so you can ride in sneakers or clip in.

Choose Peloton Cross Training Bike if…

Choose the Peloton Cross Training Bike if you want Peloton's classes on a bike built for them, a built-in screen that swivels for strength and yoga, and you will keep an All-Access membership.

Schwinn Schwinn IC4 product photo
Best for
  • · Peloton-curious buyers who want the classes without Peloton hardware
  • · Riders who already own SPD cycling shoes and want a real bike feel
  • · Households that share a tablet or iPad and do not need a built-in screen
Peloton Peloton Cross Training Bike product photo
Best for
  • · Riders who want Peloton's classes on Peloton hardware for well under the Bike+
  • · Households that will use the swivel screen for strength and yoga classes too
  • · Small rooms: Peloton puts the footprint at 4 x 2 ft
$1,295.00Buy on Amazon

Spec-by-spec

SpecSchwinn IC4Peloton Cross Training Bike
ResistanceMagnetic (100 levels)Magnetic, manual knob
ConnectivityBluetooth FTMS—
PedalsSPD + toe cageAluminum, Delta-compatible cleats
Flywheel40 lb perimeter-weighted—
Display—21.5" HD swivel touchscreen
Speakers—Front-facing, 10 W total (Peloton)
Rider fit—4'11" to 6'5", up to 297 lb (Peloton)
Dimensions—54" L x 23" W x 61" H; 129 lb (Peloton)

Schwinn IC4

$799.00checked Nov 18, 2026
Buy on Amazon

Peloton Cross Training Bike

$1,295.00checked Nov 18, 2026
Buy on Amazon

Schwinn IC4

Strengths
  • +Rides along with Peloton app classes
  • +Bluetooth FTMS
  • +Dual-sided SPD pedals
  • +Magnetic resistance
Weaknesses
  • −No touchscreen (use your iPad)
  • −100 resistance levels via dial (not auto)
  • −Shipping can be delayed

Peloton Cross Training Bike

Strengths
  • +Peloton's class library on a bike built for it
  • +21.5-inch swivel screen turns for off-bike classes
  • +4 x 2 ft footprint, per Peloton
Weaknesses
  • −Manual resistance knob, no auto-resistance
  • −All-Access membership needed for the classes
  • −Pedals need Delta-compatible cycling shoes

Before you buy: where each one falls short

Schwinn IC4

Skip it if
  • ·You want auto-adjusting resistance synced to instructor cadence
  • ·You require a built-in touchscreen and do not want to BYO tablet
  • ·You weigh more than 300 pounds, the rated user weight ceiling
  • ·You want explicit Peloton hardware integration with leaderboard auto-sync
What owners complain about
  • ·Resistance is manual via dial, not auto-adjusting, so instructor cues require you to turn the knob yourself
  • ·The Peloton app cannot read the IC4’s resistance or output, so owners follow Peloton cues by feel and leaderboard numbers are not comparable
  • ·Console is basic LCD with no streaming capability, requiring a tablet for class content

Peloton Cross Training Bike

Skip it if
  • ·You want the bike to change resistance for you (that is the Bike+)
  • ·You do not plan to keep an All-Access membership
  • ·You ride in regular trainers and do not want cycling shoes

The real tradeoff

Screen and ecosystem versus freedom. The Cross Training Bike gives you a built-in 21.5-inch swivel screen and Peloton's class library, but the classes need the All-Access membership, and its pedals take Delta-compatible cleats, so budget for cycling shoes. The IC4 asks you to bring a tablet, and the Peloton app cannot read its resistance or output, so leaderboard numbers are not comparable. The Cross Training Bike is a new listing with few owner ratings so far.

Skip both if…

Skip both if you want the bike to change resistance for you. That is the Peloton Cross Training Bike+, which adds auto-resistance and a movement-tracking camera. Browse Exercise Bikes.

Buyer questions

Can the Schwinn IC4 run Peloton classes?

As a ride-along, yes: stream Peloton app classes on your own tablet and turn the dial when the instructor calls a level. The app does not read the IC4's resistance or output. Apps that read Bluetooth FTMS, like Zwift, can read the bike directly.

Does the Peloton Cross Training Bike work with Zwift?

No. It is a closed ecosystem that runs Peloton's own classes, with no Zwift or third-party data. If open apps matter to you, the IC4's Bluetooth FTMS is the reason to pick it.

Do I need a membership for the Peloton Cross Training Bike?

For the classes, yes. Peloton's All-Access membership unlocks its content on Peloton hardware and is sold separately. The IC4 can use Peloton's cheaper app plan on your own tablet instead.

What is the difference between the Cross Training Bike and the Bike+?

Per Peloton, the Cross Training Bike has a 21.5-inch swivel screen and a manual resistance knob. The Bike+ has a 23.8-inch swivel screen, auto-resistance that follows the instructor, a movement-tracking camera and Sonos-tuned speakers.

Your next step

Not sold on either? See the full ranked field.

Full review: Schwinn IC4 →Full review: Peloton Cross Training Bike →All Exercise Bikes →